We are not veteran cruisers. This was our first time. We travel, but usually stay somewhere for a few days, packing and unpacking, traveling by land or air.
To celebrate a milestone wedding anniversary, we booked a 7 day cruise from Vancouver, BC to Whittier, AK for ourselves, as well as our adult children and their spouses—a total of three staterooms.
We had one issue that was non-negotiable, which was that we wanted king-size beds. This limited our choice of both cruise lines and cabins, and we ended up booking Neptune Suites on Holland America Line Nieuw Amsterdam (NA). A friend had sailed on this ship a few years earlier, and recommended it.
We booked 14 months in advance, via Costco Travel, so we could get the Have It All early booking bonus, including Elite Drink Package, Premium internet and included pre-paid gratuities.
We booked a mid to late May cruise because, well costs would have been significantly higher for the the choicer parts of the summer. It was a bonus that there were few kids on this cruise.
Booking process was easy, and the cash back bonus from Costco, as well as travel credit on the Costco Visa from Citi and Costco Executive 2%. All in, I think we got discounts of about 6%.
Embarkation was a dread, but went remarkably smoothly. They kept people moving at Canada Place. If there was some benefit to having the Neptune Suite, I did not appreciate it. I did not see a Priority Boarding area.
We boarded around noon, but our suites were not ready. We chilled on the Lido with some drinks that were credited to our room. Our server tried to upsell us to the Retreat area. I passed, figuring we weren’t going to be outside much in a cabana. The upselling became a recurrent theme of the trip, as there were frequent appeals from waitstaff to upsell our drinks and food choices. Could have done without that.
Eventually cabins were ready, although our bags were not there. In fact, even several hours later, only 3 of 4 bags had been delivered. I went to the aft elevator lobby and found our fourth bag and brought it back to the cabin.
The Neptune Suites were very nice. Ample space for storage, even for My Beloved, who is an admitted overpacker. I felt the bed was comfortable, but My Beloved has a bad back. After calling our Neptune Lounge concierge, a foam topper was added after the first night, and she was pleased. There were a few things missing from our Suite, such as a cup for using the coffee machine (which we didn’t use anyway) and an umbrella. The binoculars and blankets are a nice touch for enjoying the balcony on this chilly Alaskan passage. Our cabin steward, Victor, was friendly and efficient. Unlimited laundry was wonderful, as we spent four nights in Vancouver prior to embarkation, and another 5 days in Denali (on our own itinerary, not Cruisetour) after disembarkation.
A great benefit of the Neptune Suites is the Neptune Lounge. Our concierges, Lorraine and Pearl, were friendly, professional and very competent. I cannot speak highly enough of them. They gave our family a detailed orientation to the benefits of our suite, and even helped us log int the Navigator app on the ship. The Neptune Lounge was well stocked with food and beverages throughout our trip, and we found it a quiet place to go to decompress after a long day of shore excursions and exploring the very crowded ports. One doesn’t need a Neptune Lounge, but it was very much a “nice to have”.
The Navigator app is essential, but unfortunately is very kludgy. Logging in was difficult, as we had to uncheck several security settings on our iPhones to make a connection to the ship WiFi to use the app. Additionally, our phones kept dropping off the network during the cruise, even on sea days when we didn’t leave the ship, and we had to keep trying to reconnect with the WiFi. Very frustrating! However, once connected, internet speeds were quite good. However, once we got the app going, it was a very easy and effective way to request laundry pick up and order food from Dive In and NY Pizza. Having the itinerary on the app was also nice.
Food on NA ran from fair to excellent. For breakfast, we dined mostly at the Pinnacle Grill, a perk of the Neptune Suite (or Club Orange)enjoying the quiet, and excellent service. Menu is same as the main dining room. We did have breakfast once a the Lido Market, but did not enjoy waiting on line for food. However, the food at Lido Market is quite good. The only missteps we encountered was very dry short rib for two of us at Pinnacle Grill, but it was easily sent back and replaced with a different dish. We also ran into an overcooked creme brûlée in the Main Dining Room. Meals at Tamarind and Morimoto were outstanding—A++. I enjoyed the NY Pizza and Dive In burgers and hot dogs, but others in our group were unimpressed. MDR was mostly quite good, but not as good as the specialty restaurants, with respect to service or food quality or even quantity. We had one room service breakfast, on Glacier Bay day, and one afternoon tea in our cabin, on the last sea day.
Everywhere you turn on this ship, there is a bar, and our Elite package covered most drinks, although high end whiskeys, which the waiter often pushed, would add additional charges. We enjoyed the creative cocktails and the excellent beer selections. Our kids our coffee drinkers, and really enjoyed the fast and efficient baristas in the Crows Nest. The barista in the Lido Market was slow, and should be avoided.
I used the fitness center several times and it is excellent—better than any hotel gym I have used. One of our group booked the week long thermal pass, and really enjoyed it. My Beloved and I booked a couples massage, and found it a bit lackluster compared to other hotel spas. Again, there was attempt to upsell products at the end of the massage, which we have not experienced at other hotels or resorts.
We really enjoyed interacting with the naturalist, Dom, as well as National Park Service Rangers who boarded in Glacier Bay. Both Glacier Bay and College Fjord gave great glacier viewing, although only Glacier Bay seemed to have the narrative as we cruised.
Excursions for our group were excellent. However, the ports were quite busy. Really, did not enjoy port days, with so many cruise ships in port, the streets get crowded and the restaurants and shopkeepers are stressed. However, we did have a very nice lunch at Skagway Brewing. I expect that ports are quite different when the cruise ships are gone. We stayed overnight in Venice, Italy and Lerwick, Scotland, and they are completely different, and more relaxed, when cruise ship passengers have left. I imagine Ketchikan, Juneau and Skagway are the same.
The ship docks very early in Whittier, and our concierge noted that I had not booked a transfer with HAL for that port. Instead, through VIator, I booked an all day private transfer and tour of Anchorage, including bird sanctuary, Wildlife sanctuary and Earthquake park. Disembarkation was well organized on the ship, but a bit hectic in the terminal to claim our bags and find our rides.
So would I recommend booking the same cruise on the same ship in the future for the same trip—absolutely! Am I a “cruise person” now? Not really. I certainly see the appeal, and wish we had done a cruise in Galapagos, rather than staying on the islands. For the right itinerary, there is a great benefit to have your hotel move from place to place at night, and only unpack once. But having encountered cruisers from time to time on other travels (France, Italy, Scotland, Jamaica, Costa Rica, etc), I think they miss out on some essential cultural interactions by sticking with a cruise ship.